Brandon and I were both public schooled. So, we don't have any real personal insight into how Christian school or homeschooling might be better or worse for Noah. I personally received a great education from my public school, but certainly it was a secular education.
What we want most is what is most glorifying to God and most beneficial to Noah's soul and mind. We aren't sold that public school is the answer, but neither are we sold on Christian schooling or homeschooling.
In R.C. Sproul Jr.'s book, When You Rise Up: A Covenantal Approach to Homeschooling
While I appreciate Sproul's vigor in making his arguments and agreed with many his points about schooling, I did not agree with his overall thesis. The first point he argues, that character is more important than knowledge is one that I can concur. I would much rather my son go to heaven than be smart. I think deep down inside we all feel this way, even if we are not living this way. But his second, more strongly stated point, that homeschooling is the only way of obeying God in educating children, goes a little off the deep end for me. Sproul is so enthused about his belief in homeschooling, that he argues that if you are a parent that entitles you to the ability to teach your children; that if you don't understand a subject area, skip it because it's not that important; and (by way of a personal example) if a child is unable to read by the age of 9 it's not a sign of failure if he/she shows signs of godliness.
Again, I agree with Sproul that godliness is more important to cultivate than book intelligence, but how is outsourcing my children to others wrong when I am obviously failing my child in head knowledge and others are better equipped to handle this work?
I do give Sproul props for addressing most people's issues with homeschooling. He doesn't avoid the common questions of socialization issues and the burden of homeschooling. However, I don't agree with all of his answers. Sproul addresses the question of, "what about the poor? Don't they need access to free education?" Sproul's answer is no, that even in tough situations and parents without proper education themselves, they are still called to educate their own children. I think this is a ridiculous answer and a short-sighted answer. If Mom and Dad are illiterate (assuming there is a mom AND a dad), how are they going to be capable of teaching their children. What about mental health issues present in parents? What about single moms who work 60 hours a week? I know I sound like a liberal asking the specific regarding a general statement, but I found no wiggle room in Sproul's book. To Sproul, homeschooling equals obeying God and all other forms of education fall short of honoring God.
Sproul Jr. and I agree that God does command me to educate Noah about God. That in all I do and say around Noah, I should be educating my son about God. However, I am not so much convinced that word of God is compelling me to teach my son about calculus because frankly, I know nothing about calculus (sorry Dr. Saunders!). If Noah, however, excels in math, why would I just "skip that subject?" Isn't my ignorance hindering Noah's calling from God to be a mathematician (whether or not that his call who knows)? Many of my homeschooling friends do co-ops or will bring in tutors to cover subjects that they are unable to teach. I do not see a difference in this and sending them to a Christian school (or even many public schools).
I would recommend Sproul Jr.'s book to you because it is written from a perspective that I have heard few utter before. I also suspect that many homeschooling parents feel the same way Sproul does, they just don't have the audacity to say it aloud or, more permanently, write it in ink. Perhaps one day I feel differently about this book, maybe after making schooling decisions for Noah I will be more like Sproul, but on this day, I stand in disagreement with his conclusions. This, however, does not mean that Brandon and I will not homeschool. We very well may. When You Rise Up: A Covenantal Approach to Homeschooling
How do you feel about homeschooling? What has informed your decisions on how to educate your children?